Please forward your question in our support forum.

This: http://pastebin.com/6PUvfbGg does get me close, but still, it seems that once again the third paged page disappears when I am on second page … arghh!!

Hi Anastis,
I appreciate it! Will check that stack and see if I can really understand what is kickin’ in (tho at first glance, i am not confident as i think i had already seen and tested that example).

Thank you a bunch!

You didn’t mention that you wanted a different number of posts in subsequent pages. That’s a whole different issue. This StackExchange thread will help you with this issue.

As far as the notice is concerned, I can’t help you without seeing the backtrace. Any query-related code could be to blame, even from a plugin.

Hi Anastis,
Thank you. That brought back the 2 missing posts, but now it won’t change the number of posts on paged pages , it keeps them all on 2 posts per page as opposed to 2 on homepage and 4 on paged pages.

Also with wp_debug true, I am getting the next: Notice: Trying to get property of non-object in /../\wp-includes\query.php on line 4337

But at least, the pagination is working as it should ;)

Oooops! It’s actually is_front_page()
My bad! I’ve fixed all references in my previous comments. Give it a spin and let me know.